green hermit dimorphism

investigating the difference in bill shape between male and female Green Hermits

The Green Hermit (Phaethornis guy) is a tropical species of hummingbird that engages in aggressive leks during the breeding season. This species is also notable for its bill sexual dimorphism, in which females have visibly curvier bills than males. Prior studies discovered a sharp, daggerlike structure on the male bill tip which could represent an example of weaponry in birds. We wanted to explore whether or not the different bill shape in males could provide structural advantages during combat, which would provide further support the potential weapon.

We utilized PicoCam's photogrammetry to generate 3D models from museum specimens and analyzed their morphology with both precision measurements and Finite Element Analysis (a mechanical force simulation). Through this we showed that male bills are significantly straighter, stronger and sharper than female bills, indicating the sexual dimorphism might benefit male green hermits who spar with their bills during intense leks.

Right: Female and Male Green Hermit (Phaethornis guy) to demonstrate differences in bill shape. Both images obtained from Wikimedia Commons. Female Credit: Cephas, CC BY-SA 4.0. Male Credit: Kathy & sam from Beaverton OR, USA, CC BY 2.0.
Graphical abstract of hermit bill measurements. (A) 3D photogrammetry model with landmarks used to quantify bill shape and selected area to quantify surface area. Close-up of the bill-tip (right) showing the outer maxillary areas used to calculate the sharpness ratio. (B) P. guy hypothetical stabbing behavior based on P. longirostris fight. (C) Boundary conditions for finite element analyses simulating stabbing behavior using 3D CT models. Loads were applied at two different angles from the bill-tip.

This project was published in Journal of Experimental Biology and had a lot of press! There was a great Inside JEB article written about the paper in the same issue, and we were interviewed for a piece in UW News! There were also articles in Scientific American and Smithsonian Magazine.

I also was invited to do a guest Q&A about the paper for a class at the University of Cincinnati: BIOL 3041, Biology of Sex!

Cover photo: A female Green Hermit (Phaethornis guy). Credit: Jan Lenaert